Introduction to Hyaluronic Acid
Hyaluronic acid (HA) is a linear polysaccharide occurring naturally in the synovial fluid, the extracellular matrix of connective tissue, and other tissues. It has several structural & physiological functions, such as tissue lubrication, regulation of osmotic pressure, growth factors interactions, and cellular/extracellular interactions. These function helps to maintain the tissue's homeostatic & structural integrity.1 Evidences on the physicochemical properties and physiological role have shown it as an ideal for medical, pharmaceutical, and cosmetic purposes.2
HA plays a vital role in migration, cell adhesion, and differentiation mediated by numerous binding proteins and cell-surface receptor CD44.3, 4 Additionally, the negative charge and substantial size of HA allow it to take in lots of water and exert pressure on the nearby tissue, producing an expansion of the extracellular space. Henceforth, HA uses a buffering action to the masticatory forces on the periodontal ligament. Additionally, it holds anti-inflammatory and bacteriostatic effects.5 It also has a major role in almost all the phases of wound treatment.6
HA enables cell migration and isolation throughout tissue regeneration. Application of exogenic HA is beneficial in experimental animals for wound healing.7, 8
In dentistry, the preliminary clinical trials on HA were conducted way back in 1997. A study by Vangelisti, Pagnacco et al. (1997) revealed that hyaluronate possesses anti-inflammatory, bacteriostatic and anti-edematous effects which can have a potential role in the treatment of gingivitis as well as periodontitis. Exogenic HA shows anti-inflammatory effects by exhausting metalloproteinases, prostaglandins, and other bioactive molecules.9 Anti-edematous effects were associated with osmotic activity. The high concentration of LMW HA has the most bacteriostatic effect as it stimulates the phagocytic activity of macrophages.It was used as an adjunct to mechanical therapy due to HA’s tissue healing properties.10 Nevertheless, it is plausible that HA could be effective in periodontal tissue regeneration as well as in periodontal disease treatment.11, 12 This review helps to more thoroughly understand the biochemical and pharmacological role of HA in post periodontal surgery.
History & Chemistry of HA
History
French scientist Portes noted that mucin from the vitreous body of eye was not the same as other mucoids in cornea and cartilage and termed it "hyalomucine" way back in 1880. However, it was only in 1934 that Meyer and Palmer isolated a polysaccharide consisting of an amino sugar and a uronic acid from bovine vitreous humor and called it Hyaluronic acid , derived from "hyaloid" and "uronic acid." 13 In 20th century, a gradual awareness about biological functions established HA’s advancement as a medicine for several therapies. The extraction of HA from animal tissues were increasingly enhanced, nonetheless had issues of contamination from microorganisms or proteins. To date, bacterial fermentation is one of the favorable methods for production of HMW Hyaluronic acid. Although, there are different sources to extract Hyaluronic acid, the variety of bacteria produces HA and stimulates bacterial fermentation. The most important pre-purification steps include centrifugation and numerous precipitations along with polar solvents, though ultrafiltration & size exclusion chromatography are the most chosen method for purification.14
Chemistry
The HA is a linear chain consisting of recurring disaccharide connected with ß 1,4-glycosidic bond. Disaccharide individually contains d-glucuronic acid and N-acetyl-d-glucosamine connected by ß-1,4 -glycosidic bond.15 HA is negatively charged because of carboxylate groups. Thus, it forms hydrophilic salts with distinctive capacity of binding and retaining H2O, which allows tremendous viscoelasticity, biocompatibility, hygroscopic properties great and water retention capacity. Thus, it plays a role as a lubricant, water balance retention–flow-resistant regulator, space filler, and shock absorber.14
Physical & Biological Properties of HA
HA is widely found in humans as well as in animals, which include rabbits, roosters, bovines, and bacteria. The total content of HA in human is about 15 g for a 70-kg adult. Cells are surround by HA and in the extracellular matrix (ECM) of connective tissues.16, 17
Hyaluronic acid has the following properties
Hygroscopic nature: HA is highly hygroscopic in nature. After Hyaluronic acid contained into an aq. solution, Hydrogen appears among the adjacent; acetyl and carboxyl groups, which maintains conformational stiffness and retain water. It functions as physical background material in space-filling, shock absorption and lubrication.
Bacteriostatic effect: Evidence on regenerative operative procedures indicates that reducing bacterial burden at the wound area improves regenerative treatment. Elevated concentration of moderate to lower MW Hyaluronic acid has the most significant bacteriostatic effect, more specifically on Prevotella oris, Aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans, & Staphylococcus aureus strains, which are mainly observed in periodontal as well as in gingival wounds. Use of hyaluronic acid during surgeries reduces the contamination around the wound, thus reducing the possibility of post-operative infection and fostering inevitable regeneration.18
Viscoelastic properties: HA helps in periodontal regenerative processes by sustaining spaces and surfaces. The viscoelastic properties slow down the infiltration of viruses and bacteria in treating periodontal diseases.18
Anti-oedematous: HA exhibits a non-ideal osmotic pressure, which improves exponentially instead of linearly with rising concentration of hyaluronan. This property provides HA osmotic buffering capacity, which possibly regulates the water content in a tissue.10
Antioxidant: HA behave as an antioxidant by scavenging ROS and controls inflammatory responses. Therefore, it might help to steady the granulation tissue matrix.19
Biocompatibility & non-antigenicity: The high biocompatible and non-immunogenic environment of HA results in various proven functions, such as fluid in arthriti9; and also in facilitating the regeneration/ healing of bone, periodontal tissue and surgical wounds.10
Anti-inflammatory: Anti-inflammatory effect of HA is because of its exogenous role by draining metalloproteinases, prostaglandins, and other bio-active molecules.
Role of HA in healing of periodontal tissues
Healing of periodontal tissue involves phases of extremely reproducible and firmly regulated biologic events that gather and debride the wounded tissue, foreign substance, and microbial cells [Figure 1, Figure 2]. Phases ends with the growth and maturation of ECM which restores tissue endurance.20, 21
Inflammatory phase: In the early stages of inflammation, HA plays a number of tasks. For example, it interacts with the fibrin clot to provide structural support, which controls the infiltration and ECM into the inflammatory area. According to Hakansson et al. HA in adherence and migration of macrophages and polymorphonuclear leukocytes at the inflamed region, phagocytosis & destroying invasive microbes. Such events would agree to lessen the colonization and proliferation of anaerobic pathogen in gingival crevice & nearby periodontal tissues.22 HA also inhibit periodontal pathogen colonization by directly preventing microbial proliferation. HA produces proinflammatory cytokines by fibroblasts,osteoblasts, cementoblasts and keratinocytes which boost the inflammatory response & subsequently promote HA production by endothelial cells. It indirectly acts to lessen the inflammation & alleviate the granulation tissue through blocking degradation of the ECM proteins by serine proteinases obtained from inflammatory cells as healing continues.23, 24
Granulation phase & re-epithelization: HA stimulates proliferationof cell, converts matrix cells into granulation tissue matrix. Hyaluronic acid in mineralized tissues progressively switched by a temporary mineralized callus.25, 26 During late granulation phase, existing HA is depolymerized by hyaluronidases instigating the development of LMW HA & an modification in the composition of the granulation tissue. LMW HA fragments produce after hyaluronidase action stimulate the production of angiogenesis inside wound area.27
Bone regeneration: HA increase bone regeneration due to proliferation, chemotaxis and variation of mesenchymal cells. Hayaluronic acid shares bone induction qualities with osteopontin and bone morpho genetic protein 2.28, 29
Studies of HA in periodontal tissue healing and regeneration
Studies based on the use of HA in post peridontal surgery, gingivitis, peridontitis were included. Clinical studies were searched in Google Scholar and PubMed using keywords ("hyaluronic acid" and "post-periodontal surgery"), ("hyaluronic acid" and "periodontitis"), ("hyaluronic acid" and "gingivitis").
HA in gingivitis
HA has emerged as a beneficial adjuvant in the management of gingivitis. Jentsch et al. 2003 revealed that 0.2% HA twice daily for three weeks is effective in patients affected by gingivitis, improvise PI, PBI, and GCF.30 Pistorius et al. 2005 also showed that HA reduces SBI, PBI values, and GCF. 31 Likewise, Sahayata et al.2014 revealed that g,0.2% HA gel in inflamed gingiva for four weeks adjunctly with oral hygiene & scaling resulted in significant improvement in the GI and PBI.32
Table 1
Overview of clinical trials
HA in chronic periodontitis
The HA gel decreases cell proliferation in epithelial cells including lymphocytes, fibroblasts and subsides the inflammatory response and periodontal lesion in chronic periodontitis.33 Johannsen et al.2009 noted that twice subgingival administrations of 0.8% Hyaluronic acid gel reduce bleeding in the treatment group.34 Comparably, Polepalle et al.,2015 demonstrated that application of 0.8% Hyaluronic acid gel for seven days, reduced the BOP, plaque index, PPD, CAL, and CFU.35 Gontiya et al., 2012 noted that application of 0.2 % Hyaluronic acid gel with Scaling & root planning (SRP) in chronic periodontitis patients improved the GI and BI and decreased in inflammatory infiltrate.36
Rajan et al. 2014 showed that Hyaluronic acid application directly after Scaling & root planning and seven days post therapy is effective in chronic periodontitis. Combined treatment demonstrated a considerable progress in all clinical parameters: BOP, PPD, and CAL, at 12 weeks post-therapy compared with SRP alone.37
Bevilacqua et al.2012 showed that 0.5 mL of amino acids and HA gel subsequent to ultrasonic mechanical instrumentation reduced PPD and BOP in moderate to severe chronic periodontitis in comparison to ultrasonic debridement alone.38
HA in post-periodontal surgery
El-Sayed et al. 2012 evaluated the clinical impact of hyaluronan gel (0.8%) in combination with periodontal surgery. Substantial improvement (P < 0.05) was observed in the treatment and the control site after 3 & 6 months. The treatment site displayed greater improvement in clinical attachment level (CAL) & reduction in gingival recession (GR).39 Leonardo et al. 2009 examined the clinical efficiency of esterified HA for periodontal imperfections. During the study, nineteen defects (one mandibular molar and eighteen infrabony furcation) were treated using hyaluronic acid fibers. One year treatment displayed 5.8 mm reduction in the mean probing pocket depth (PPD) and 3.8 mm benefit in the attachment.40 Briguglio et al.2013 investigated the use of HA for the treatment of infrabony periodontal defects. The mean CAL gain of 1.9 ± 1.8 mm, was obtained with PD reduction of 1.6 ± 1.2 mm.41 Pilloni et al. 2012, assessed the benefit of hyaluronic acid gel on periodontal considerations. Study results that HA gel has an effect in alleviating the inflammation of gingival and increase the periodontal CI.42 Olszewska-Czyz et al. 2021 suggested that HA has greater gain in clinical attachment and reduced bleeding on probing, which indicates reduced inflammation and periodontal regeneration.43 According to Ballini et al. 2009, HA has good abilities for regeneration of bone in infrabony defects.44
Abbreviations: papillary bleeding index -PBI, and gingival crevicular fluid-GCF, sulcus bleeding index -SBI gingival index -GI, bleeding on probing- BOP, plaque index — PI, bleeding on probing pocket depth -PPD, clinical attachment level-CAL, and colony-forming units-CFUs, bleeding index-BI, probing pocket depth-PPD
To summarize, Hyaluronic Acid is broadly used in several branches of medicine with potential use in dentistry to treat inflammatory diseases. In the periodontium, hyaluronic acid is present in smaller amount in mineralized tissues while abundant in non-mineralized tissues.
While SRP is the first step in the management of periodontal diseases, use of adjuvants along with antibiotics has been advocated in multiple clinical studies in the past. Hyaluronic acid, due to its multi-functional role has emerged as a potential adjuvant along with SRP to help improve the clinical parameters in re-gaining periodontal health.
The periodontal wound healing comprises sequence of reproducible & firmly controlled biological actions, including inflammation, epithelium formation, granulation tissue formation & tissue remodeling. During the inflammatory phase, it forms a structural framework by interacting with fibrin clot and helps to prevent pathogen colonization by directly preventing microbial proliferation. In the granulation phase, HA stimulates proliferation of cells, movement of matrix cells into granulation tissue matrix. The fragments formed due to HA also helps to boost the development of blood vessels (angiogenesis) in wound sites. Furthermore, Hyaluronic acid speeds up rejuvenation of bone by proliferation, chemotaxis and isolation of mesenchymal cells.
Conclusion
It is evident from the various clinical studies that local application of HA has a multifactorial function in the treatment of chronic periodontitis and even after post-periodontal surgery for the repair and regeneration of periodontal tissues and alveolar bone. Due to its versatile nature and exceptional physicochemical properties, HA has been used in various forms and concentrations and has reported favorable clinical outcomes as seen in different clinical studies which further confirm HA's beneficial effects in wound healing and tissue regeneration.
Article DOI
